Man kills serial pedophile
Monday, Dec. 8 2008 @ 4:22PM
An Associated Press video report about Michael Mele, a person of interest in the abduction of Laura Garza.
He's only 23, but Michael Mele, late of Walkill in Upstate New York, has graduated quickly from registered sex offender to suspected killer. Police in New York believe that Mele, the son of a former assistant deputy chief of police, had something to do with the disappearance of pretty 25-year-old Laura Garza, of Brooklyn.
Garza was last seen leaving a New York City nightclub with Mele and another man on the night of December 3. Garza, who had recently come to New York from McAllen, Texas, met Mele at the Marquee in Manhattan that Wednesday night. She probably had no idea as to what she was dealing with.
Michael Mele was sentenced early in 2008 on charges related to "forcible touching." He would approach women at the Palisades Center Mall in Clarkstown, NY. Mele would sometimes touch and masturbate on his victims. Police in Clarkstown nabbed Mele after they matched his DNA to semen found on the clothes of one of his victims.
Since he had no previous record, Mele was granted six years' probation after pleading guilty to the most serious charge against him. He was placed on the New York State sex offender registry at level 1. In most states, level 1 offenders are generally regarded as the least likely to re-offend. The police chief of Clarkstown, however, told ABC News that Mele was "a crazy sucker," and that Mele's behavior was "escalating." Chief Bernard Cummings also said, "In all my years, seeing this kind of behavior is a little off the radar here."
Michael Mele hasn't been charged with anything in connection with the disappearance of Laura Garza. He has allegedly violated the terms of his probation: drinking, not seeing his probation officer, and not attending any sex offender treatment program. When he turned himself in it was for an outstanding warrant connected to a traffic violation.
Police have been searching in and around Mele's condo in Walkill, NY and neighbors have reported seeing troubling items picked up by the investigators, such as weapons and a woman's clothing.
Worse yet, Mele may have cleaned his apartment with bleach, and potentially most telling of all -- he allegedly had bite and scratch marks on his body when he was jailed on Friday.
According to most reports, Laura Garza came to New York for the very same reasons so many young people flock to that city -- she had dreams of becoming a dancer. Neighbors in video reports have universally described her as friendly, open, and kind. In other words, the exact sort of victim sexually predatory animals tend to seek.
Michael Mele is due back in court on December 22 to answer for his probation violations. Mele was hit with more warrants late Monday afternoon -- this time for indecent exposure, in Paramus, NJ.
[LoHud.com, ABC News. Also -- Laura Garza's private MySpace. Hat-tip to Michelle in the comments for this post.]







So ironic, I'm sure that this is her myspace page...
http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewProfile&friendID=139880850
Notice her headline...
"The only things in life you regret, are the risk that you didnt take.."
Female
25 years old
NEW YORK, Texas
United States
Last Login: 12/1/2008
Poor Laura, he was not worth the risk :( I'm hoping and praying they find you soon. My thoughts and prayers are with you and your family.
Posted 12/08/2008 at 05:54:27 PMWith his Dad being ex-LE I expect this to be a tough case. I am sure he's being given lots of "advice". At least he is off the streets. Hopefully forever.
Posted 12/08/2008 at 09:28:17 PMThis case is heartbreaking. I hope that she did not suffer before she died. He is scum and I hope they find enough to get this guy off the streets forever.
I do want to say though that young women (me included) HAVE to be careful about who we trust. We cannot just leave a club with an attractive man we just met. We just can't do that. We have to protect ourselves and make smart choices. Don't get me wrong. Laura was a victim and she did not deserve to be preyed on like that.
Posted 12/09/2008 at 08:48:41 AMBecs, I hate to tell you that if he had bites and scratches on him then you can pretty much assume that she suffered before she died. Think of what would make you bite someone hard enough to leave a mark and scratch at their neck.
If he's guilty I hope he gets the death penalty.
Posted 12/09/2008 at 02:32:45 PMKat, I agree. And no matter if death was quick, the knowledge of being in trouble, in danger for her life, means she suffered terribly.
Unfortunately, some bad choices mean we don't get a second chance to get it right.
Posted 12/09/2008 at 06:26:06 PMWhat a sick scumbag. Ladies, please carry a weapon of some sort in your purse. My friend has Mace and I carry a knife. If you saw me, I'm the last girl you'd think was going to be "thugged out." Just like this clown probably seemed harmless to Laura - you just don't know who you're messing with. He would have been in for a rude awakening if he assaulted me in a mall parking lot.
Posted 12/09/2008 at 08:05:55 PM"laura solo 2 dias mas..."
that's her status on her myspace page, which she last logged into on december 1st. if she died on december 3rd, that's a really sad and ominous status :\ her mood is also listed as "impatient" - i wonder what she was excited for on the 3rd.
Posted 12/10/2008 at 03:39:46 PMPoor Laura, saw her a couple of times she worked for Charlotte Russe at the Plaza Mall in Mcallen, Tx. She looked sweet and innocent very kind and helpful at her job. I think about her everyday where can she be, or where at, and how can someone do that to her, how?? Hope they find you soon. My prayers and thoughts are with you and your family.
Posted 12/10/2008 at 06:07:30 PMI REMEMBER LAURA SHE WAS MY DAUGHTERS FRIEND. SHE WAS SWEET KIND PERSON. I GOT TO TALK TO HER SEVERAL TIMES AT CHARLLOTTE RUSSE WHERE BOTH MY DAUGHTER AND HER USED TO WORK. I FEEL SO SAD THAT THIS IS HAPPENING TO LAURA. I HOPE SOME ONE CAN TELL US WHERE SHE IS AT. I PRAY FOR HER FAMILY THAT THE LORD GIVES THEM CONFORT. I ALSO PRAY THAT THE LORD PUT A CONVICTION ON THE PERSON THAT HARMED LAURA. HE SHOULD BE LOCK UP.
Posted 12/11/2008 at 10:06:42 PMlauren,
I saw that too. Do you think that she met this guy through myspace and agreed to meet up with him at the club? Maybe she didn't leave with a stranger, maybe she chatted with him online and agreed to meet. Has the authorities checked her email/myspace page???
Posted 12/13/2008 at 12:18:31 PMI believe that everything happens for a reason; however sometimes things can be prevented... In this corrupted world, one must understand the damages and consequences of every day action. The poor girl, (like millions) moved to New York, decided to meet new people, and ended up in the wrong place at the wrong time... What is odd to me,is that she was described as a good girl that apparently came back to the house every night, so its iffy to me that she even left with an unknown person. Also, I don't really think people should convict Mele, because of his past actions, just because he did some kinky stuff in the past, nobody is perfect. And although, he was the last person that was seen with her, it doesn't make him all guilty. Maybe she left the club with him, slept over his house that night, and left that morning, and somebody raped her. The problem with the media today is that it trys to cover up the truth of what could've happened... But if it was Mele that committed the crime, than he needs to start talking, because he is getting everybody worried even in Miami! I hope that she is alive. My blessings go out to the family. I will keep praying for that beautiful, young girl that was in the wrong place at the wrong time....
Posted 12/17/2008 at 04:13:25 PMto maxiell...i know we dont want to be quick to judge and its innocent until proven guilty. however i live in the upstate new york area where the investigation is taking place. she was seen with mele between 4-5 am in newburgh (a local city). at that point there was someone else in the car with him. the witness let them shortly after. by 11 am that same morning mele was calling the witness asking if he heard anything about garza's disappearance. police records show laura wasnt reported missing until 5 pm that night. how would he know she was missing before the police did if he didnt have a hand in it. the witness also asked mele if he (the witness) was going to be in any sort of trouble. mele responded to this by saying..." you dont have anything to worry about you didnt do anything wrong." to me an admission of guilt. the large squares of carpet missing from his apartment bedroom and the bite and nail scratches are just the icing on the cake. this creep is guilty and i would suggest life in jail without parole as a mich better alternative to the death penalty. why let him get off that easy?
Posted 12/18/2008 at 08:08:17 PMI wonder if the police checked Mele's myspace to see if it was a pre-arranged visit - meaning if they first met via the internet prior to in person...
Posted 12/18/2008 at 09:16:37 PMI usually get really irritated about all the bad rap given to myspace, when its not the website, it the individual people..
but anyway,
I have been racking my brain about where I know the name from, and I think its because Mele is a guy that used to hit on me on myspace, and brag constantly about all his money & fast cars in a very bad boy, but still kind bi-polar manic way... would get "angry" really easy.
I read that a women in WI stated she had a vision that she is still alive.
I do hope that the police follow all leads and that if she is still alive the find her before its too late.
Sending out all the best of thoughts, hopes & prayers to her family
i am a south texas /valley native, these guys obviously slipped somehting in this girls' drink to lure her out and away from her crowd, laura has already left our world from what i have read , it is sad to think of how many evil people are still out there...but really ladies you must keep it conservative and not overdo yourselves at the party scene, because when reality sets in and you snap out of your partymode/buzz you might not be in the place or circumstance you want to be in...take care & be wise
Posted 12/29/2008 at 03:52:16 PMTo all: I believe that just like allergic persons wear a bracelet to identify them, and home arrestees wear and ankle bracelet to prevent them from going out of their homes, any sex offender should wear a police bracelet to identify them in public. This could prevent many headlines like "she left with a convicted sex offender" or "the suspect is convicted sex offender...". They have done it once and not punished hard enough; hence, they will do it again. Rape should be equally punished as murder, because they will eventually kill one of their victims.
Posted 12/30/2008 at 09:32:05 AMTo Kevin, maybe its true, but there has to be a reasonable doubt, that by any means the evidence is not enough. I'm not on anyone's side; however I don't believe any women should trust a guy at such a late time period. She was as sweet as candy, but her actions spoke otherwise implicating lack of street knowledge-especially in New York. Also, if he is guilty he needs to stop acting clueless, and start answering what truly happened. Either a.) he wanted to have sex with her, and she didn't so he killed her, B.) She had sex with him, and for him it wasn't enough, so he killed her, or C.) which can be doubted, that the morning she left the house someone raped her and dumped her body far from the scene... I don't really know what happened, but this isn't really news. This happens all the time. So my advice that I give to people is trust no one, even if they have tons of money....
Posted 12/30/2008 at 02:47:59 PMTo Kevin, maybe its true, but there has to be a reasonable doubt, that by any means the evidence is not enough. I'm not on anyone's side; however I don't believe any women should trust a guy at such a late time period. She was as sweet as candy, but her actions spoke otherwise implicating lack of street knowledge-especially in New York. Also, if he is guilty he needs to stop acting clueless, and start answering what truly happened. Either a.) he wanted to have sex with her, and she didn't so he killed her, B.) She had sex with him, and for him it wasn't enough, so he killed her, or C.) which can be doubted, that the morning she left the house someone raped her and dumped her body far from the scene... I don't really know what happened, but this isn't really news. This happens all the time. So my advice that I give to people is trust no one, even if they have tons of money....
Posted 12/30/2008 at 02:49:54 PMWhy don't they just get this guy in a room and question him? Where is this girl? He probably premeditated the whole thing and cleaned up all the evidence so well that he'll get off. They can definitely tell if he's lying when they question him and by giving him a lie detector's test.
Posted 12/31/2008 at 12:33:38 PMHe sounds guilty as sin to me. They should hang him. He sounds like a real nut case. Her parents should sue the County he lives in for letting him walk the streets. That's the problem with these nutcases. They are allowed to roam the streets with a record.
Bad things happen to good people these days u cant trust anyone.I blame the up state police department for letting a person out on the street to harm another victim. when friends go out to clubs together u come and leave together story like this happens every day . u still have to enjoy life but u have to be careful no matter who we or . my heart go out to the garza family and micheal mele u need to stay where u are .
Posted 01/09/2009 at 07:31:27 PMyou know it fuck up how a a pieace of shit can just stop a beauiful woman life in matter of hour and to believe that he could get away with it.I didnt know laura but when i seen her story in the news i was very mad and so hurt i can stop thinking of her. mele is a coward, im sorry but i think he kill her and his dad,girlfriend and mom know and i understand that that they son, but what he did is wrong and he need to pay for it. you know he getaway with everything he do he should have been put away he's is a demon.I think he have done this before.it's going on three month and they have not found laura.i wish i was a detective so i can help . mele mother should feel like a coward too because how can she find in her heart to sleep good at night she selfish laura mom can find her daughter she doesn't know where she at.mele parent know where they son is. I would like to say is he made not respond to what did to the law but he sure would have to when he come to front with the biggest man and that when he is going a suffer the worst more then what he made laura suffer and his parent too . in front of our god.this is for mele and parent especially his mom because she a mom like we are how can you live with yourself she know 'that her son' .He needed help since he was a kid she didnt help him and now she have a son has a murder .I would love to go see mele and his family but they are coward,demonish,selfish,disgusting they scare to face anybody .what done is done you can do anything your son is a murder so why not face her family, when he did what he did i'm pretty sure he was thinking he was the man right. Mele so why not say where she is . for laura mom god bless you and your family. they a god looking over you and family and he is not going to but you throught more that what you can take just hold on. he is going to bring you laura i truely believe in him and i know you do too.
Posted 01/28/2009 at 11:57:00 PMTHEY SHOULD TURN THIS CASE TO THE BROOKLYN DETECTIVE THEY CAN DO A BETTER JOBS.IS JUST THAT TYPE OF CRIME REALLY DOESN'T HAPPEN UP THERE. THE UPSTATE COP DONT REALLY KNOW HOW TO HANDLE CASE LIKE THAT.A CASE LIKE THIS DONT OFTEN HAPPEN OUT THERE.UPSTATE THAT WHERE SICKO LIKE MELE LIVE AT THEY MASTER THE LAW AND THAN DO WHAT THEY WANT AND ESPECIALLY WHEN HIS FATHER IS A RETIRE TRANSIT COP. MY BROTHER IS A SARGANT AND MY SISTER WAS A COP FOR 8 YEARS UNTIL SHE PAST ON AND I BELIEVE THAT THEY WOULD NOT COVER UP ANYTHING OR ANYONE. I WAS WONDERING DID MELE HOME HAVE A BASEMENT IF YES DID THEY CHECK TO SEE IF HE BURIED HER OR IF HE BURIED HER IN HIS PARENT HOME I FEEL THAT THEY DIDNT CHECK RIGHT.I ASK MYSELF THEY SAID THEY PICK UP MELE CAR AT HIS PARENT HOME. I THOUGHT THAT HIS FATHER DIDNT SEE HIM HIS FATHER SAID HE CALL HIM AND MELE DIDNT PICK UP SO HE LEFT HIM A MESSAGE.ONE MORE THING HIS GIRL DONT KNOW ANYTHING BUT EVERYTIME SHE WENT TO SPEAK TO THE DETECTIVE SOMETHING NEW CAME UP BUT SHE DONT KNOW NOTHING.WHAT YOU CAN GET AWAY WITH WHEN YOU HAVE MONEY.
Posted 01/29/2009 at 09:37:51 PMyou want a great reality show?... "castration of pedaphiles"
Posted 02/01/2009 at 05:02:09 PMTo those who are wondering,, about what she was waiting for in two day.. I beleive that it was the lighting of the Tree in Times Square. For it was going to be her first Xmass as a New Yorker.. How sad.. We here in South Texas lost a great person in our live and You New Yorker's never had a chance to see what a wonderful,productive and positive person she really was..
Posted 02/12/2009 at 03:00:20 AMI hope you all see to it that Mele is well served by our courts and that he never see's the light of day.....
First, I'd like to pay my respects to the Garza family. I can imagine what It's like to lose a loved one. I hope I can help heal a minor part of your wound. As an optimist, I'd like to think Laura is alive and well. I'd like to share alittle premonitory insight. I'm not sure how valuable a "vision", would be appreciated. I mean no disrespect. Has the Garza family, been inside Mele's home? Lauras energy seems to guard the hallway. Laura's soul is there. From what I feel, she's haunting him. Rightfully so. That being said, please check the bear mountain location. Search the whole proximity, including the river that runs north/south. Again, this information is based on a premonitory dream I had. Hope it helps. We don't need that jerkoff harming anyone anymore!
Posted 02/14/2009 at 02:03:42 PMThe bite marks and scratches have DNA. Dental records from Laura can confirm bite marks. Cops have more than what they are letting the public know. To much information can compromise this case. No doubt this guy could be potential suspect in this case. He knows something about forensics. He is no dummy. Profiling this crime has probably already taken place. Bite marks can tell you alot of information. I pray this guy cracks the truth. Laura died a horrible death. Justice will be served.
Posted 02/17/2009 at 05:15:58 PMI just don"t understand why I'm so involved in this case...I don't read the paper as much as I should.In fact, I don't like watching the news either, But the morning that I got the paper after she was found missing, I bought the paper and went straight to her case and cried my eyes out!!! I have a really good intution and sometimes dreams come true for me.I keep seeing her and I'm so sad all the time.I thinkshe is all around us and around her family.she is trying to get someone to see what really happened but it's really hard. mele's dad has tons of experience on dealing with these crimes. I think he knows what happened and his wife doesn't have a clue and neither does the girlfriend,just the dad.I think he helped his son!! In fact,I think he called his dad right after it happened and his dad helped him hide the body.she did die a horrible death.He and the dad will pay for what happened. Unfortonately his dad is a good guy for helping sovle several rape cases and crimes. That is his son, If it were your son and you knew youcould possibly get him out of it,would you..that's what I think happened..I think he was trying to have sex with her,she didn't want to and he raped her..then choked her and was way too ruff and didn't know how ruff he was being. that's my sonopsis on this case.. Now we all have to wait to see what really happened..I drive up there on the thru way and see the sign for wallkill and it always spokes me out man!!! Do you guys know how big those mountains are!! they're huge!! and yes, I agree,BROOKLYN SHOULD GET INVOLVED!!! UPSTATE KNOWS NOTHING!!! LET THE BIG BOYS HANDLE THIS, JUST DEAL WITH TRAFFIC TICKETS,THATS ALL YOU PEOPLE KNOW HOW TO DO!!!!
Posted 03/30/2009 at 02:12:56 PMThere are many people supporting the family.
You can leave a message of support here.
http://forums.recordonline.com/n/pfx/forum.aspx?tsn=507&nav=messages&webtag=th-news&tid=10889
Posted 04/14/2009 at 01:09:18 PMI just want to wish the family a safe return of their love one. These rapist and perverts out here needs to never see the light of day if this is the kind of stuff they want to do. I beleive Mele had all to do with this. The finger is pointing right at him. I will keep you and your family in my prayers that you return home safely.
Posted 07/23/2009 at 01:47:24 PMI am Michael Mele's Aunt, I don't know what kind of life he had growing up, but I do know my sister & brother in law tried 2 raise him right. Personally, I blame the Catholic church for what Michael has become. What happened to Michael? What did they do to him & I blame his Parents partially, for feeding him that "religious crap" from the cradle. I think Michael was abused & it's a shame he had no outlet but to become what he became. It doesn't excuse his behavior, mind you, but I think we should look beyond what most of you see as a criminal. Michael, too, is a victim!!!! Thank you for listening!!!!!!!!!
Posted 08/31/2009 at 12:39:12 PMI just want to say that I know laura. I've known her for about 8 years. We worked together at charlotte and she is a very sweet girl.We went out,partied, and she never was the type to leave with anyone,so, do I believe she was drugged? maybe.although i do believe that that would be the only way she would of left with him. If she would of already had spoken to him on myspace or otherwise,her friends or co-workers would have known of him.Women talk about men that they meet whether it be serious or not so i don't believe she knew him prior to that night.(Unless the friends knew,don't know the whole story behind that) You know, it's sad to hear people defend "him" or try to justify his actions because the evidence obviously does incriminate him.I wish is was as simple as solving a case on t.v. but unfortunately we live in the real world. I speak of her in the present tense because I would love to believe that she is still with us ,somewhere, but I also have to be realistic and realize that it has almost been a year since her dissaperance. I came across a picture of us the other day at a wedding we attended in mexico and... sad very sad. All I can say now is that she will be missed and may god bless her and her family. ("he" needs to grow some #$%#s and just tell them where she is so they can get some closure.)
Posted 09/15/2009 at 12:37:52 AMI JUST WANTED TO SAY THAT IT'S ALMOST A YEAR OF LAURA'S DISAPPEARANCE. MY PRAYERS AND THOUGHTS ARE WITH THE FAMILY.
Posted 11/05/2009 at 10:42:46 AMI HOPE MICHAEL MELE WOULD HAVE SOME HEART AND SAY WHERE IS LAURA'S BODY. KEEP LOOKING FOR HER PLEASE. I WILL ALWAYS REMEMBER LAURA'S SMILE WHEN SHE WOULD GREAT ME AT CHARLOTTE. SHE WOULD ALWAYS BRIGHTEN YOUR DAY . IF YOU KNEW HER SHE WAS LIKE AN ANGEL TALKING TO YOU. WE MISS YOU LAURA. LOVE YOU WHERE EVER YOU ARE.
I live in australia and I was browsing the net and happened to see that Laura was missing. Like many others I don't read news papers or watch the news, however this one time I did.
Not being in America I don't get updated on what has happened to Laura, but I'd like to know if they've found her? I've been following this story for almost a year now and have been seeing the same story over and over again.
Is there any new leads as to where she is or what happened to her is what I'd like to know?
I don think Laura was nieve in walking out with this guy because he was a good looking bloke. She was perhaps looking for love as well as a dancing career and I don't think anyone should begrudge her that. Also I think everyone is quick to punish Mele because he was seen walking out with her... Noone really knows what happened and if Mele actually committed a crime he would be in prison for this very reason, but he's not...he's there for multiple other reasons...so it is unclear what happened to her at this point and if he is guilty.
It's sad and disturbing...but look at what type of surroundings Americans are in. Kids on the streets killing each other, familys killings there own...Guns in almost every house... Take a look at your society...its shitty. If there's one place I would never encourage my children to go it would be America... There is no serenity or calm to the place...this is not to say I hate America or Americans...it's just not a peaceful place...and certainly not safe.
I feel for Laura's family because its the ones that survive are the one's that suffer the most.. Our thoughts are with the Garza family here in Australia..
Posted 12/02/2009 at 04:01:48 AMits so upsetting to me that police have completely forgotten about Lauras case. the police in upstate NY are CORRUPT| HELLO MICHALE MELES FATHER WAS A CHIEF OF POLICE. i personally went to talk to those cops and there was like 10 of them, always the same ones...and they are VOLUNTEERS! so if this monsters father offers them money which he had plenty of , its easy for them to forget this case... so sad...... Laura, may you rest in peace.
Posted 12/09/2009 at 12:35:23 AM